University of San Diego Legal Working Paper Series
University of San Diego Public Law and Legal Theory Research Paper Series
Pursuing Justice for the Mentally Disabled
Abstract
This article considers whether lawyers act as zealous advocates when they represent mentally disordered, involuntarily committed patients who wish to assert their right to refuse treatment with psychotropic medication. After discussing a study that clearly demonstrates that lawyers do not do so, the article explores the reasons for this inappropriate behavior. Michael Perlin characterizes the problem as “sanism,” which he describes as an irrational prejudice against mentally disabled persons of the same quality and character as other irrational prejudices that cause and are reflected in prevailing social attitudes of racism, sexism, homophobia, and ethnic bigotry. The article critiques Perlin’s characterization of the problem and suggests other reasons for the phenomenon, including a belief that the civil commitment decision “proved” that the person was incompetent to make treatment decisions, and a belief that the decision on what treatment should be administered is a medical judgment to be made by the patient’s doctor and should trump any patients’ rights claim. The article concludes by considering whether aggressive advocacy would substantially improve the situation. Most patients accept–or are coerced into accepting–medication that their doctor prescribes. Because competency hearings are only conducted for those patients who assert a right to refuse medication, few patients would be affected by more aggressive attorney advocacy. Those patients who are successful in resisting coerced treatment are likely to be released from the hospital without an improvement in their mental condition and processed through the criminal justice system when they are detained in the future.
Subject Area
Civil Rights, Constitutional Law, Criminal Law and Procedure, Health Law and Policy, Human Rights Law, Medical Jurisprudence, Professional Ethics, Psychology and Psychiatry, Public Law and Legal Theory
Recommended Citation
Grant H. Morris,
"Pursuing Justice for the Mentally Disabled"
(June 2005).
University of San Diego Legal Working Paper Series.
University of San Diego Public Law and Legal Theory Research Paper Series.
Working Paper 31.
http://law.bepress.com/sandiegolwps/pllt/art31
No readers' reactions have been posted for this article. To submit one, copy the URL for this article (http://law.bepress.com/sandiegolwps/pllt/art31) and click here.